Margaret Garner (A Review)

-
So it's time to play catch-up. First we have a review for the opera Margaret Garner from Fred Allen, a colleague of mine who runs things at www.americanheritage.com. He is a trusted source when it comes to things musical, particularly classical music. Unfortunately, the news isn't good, and the reasons behind the critique sound, so I felt I should share it with you:

I saw Margaret Garner when it opened, and I have to say I was disappointed. The problem was partly the dull music but partly the story’s being very problematic for opera, for two reasons. First, you’ve got a heroine who is very morally ambiguous in a way that an opera, or at least this one, can’t get into. Killing your child is very disturbing no matter how good the reason, and killing her while letting yourself live, for whatever reason, doesn’t help. Beloved is so great because it’s about the ghost of the child coming back to haunt the mother, right? This is about the mother being a purely noble victim for killing her kid. Not so easy. Second, when you have a bad guy in an opera the bad guy tends to become the focus of energy and emotion, because bad guys are more interesting than good guys. So he’s got to be a really compelling bad guy, like Iago in Otello, who has some of the best, most passionate music in that opera. But this guy is a bad guy for institutional reasons, not for personal ones, because he’s inherited a plantation. They sort of try to address that by having him sing when he first comes on about what a sad childhood he had and how everyone picked on him so now he has to get even. But that just makes him into a pathetic bad guy. So you have a heroine you can’t completely love and a bad guy who’s more a loser and a symbol of his times than an emotional presence. Too bad. I had great hopes.
On a different note, I procrastinated getting tickets to Sharon Jones and the Dap Kings this Saturday, so if anyone goes, please send in a review.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Mr. Lorenzo DuFau and the USS Mason

-
Image
The beautiful gentleman you see above is living history. He was part of the only crew of African-American sailors to take a warship, the USS Mason , into combat during World War II. The Mason 's war record included its safe escort of convoys across the Atlantic and its exemplary service in the hunter-killer groups that finally destroyed the German U-Boats that had infested Allied waters. And for its outstanding bravery in guiding an important convoy to port in the thick of a huge storm. It would be nearly 50 years before the men would receive the commendations, (from Pres. Bill Clinton), that the convoy's commander had recommended. I know Mr. DuFau because the story of the Mason was on the cover of the second issue of American Legacy. I wasn't the editor then, but Mr. DuFau keeps in touch, dropping by the office from time to time, and attending some of our events with his wife. He is a truly sweet gentle man, who, last time he went fishing, and knowing that I love seafood, ...
Read more

“A thing is mighty big when time and distance cannot shrink it”—Zora Neale Hurston

-
Image
A Zangbeto at rest. Zangbeto are the Vodou guardians of the night among the Ogu or Egun people of Benin, Togo and Nigeria. They are charged with maintaining law and order, and keeping communities safe and secure.   In order for us to even begin to dismantle the artificial construct called race, and the racism against people of color that it serves, we need to decolonize our minds. And that begins with our origin stories. I'll let Djimon Hounsou speak in In Search of Voodoo: Roots to Heaven on YouTube movies or Amazon Prime . This is for folks who feel they'd like to begin decolonizing their minds.    Trigger Warning: There are scenes of animal sacrifice in this film. Bear in mind our own treatment of animals in the American agricultural industrial complex and how we benefit from it. Bear in mind that kosher and halal meat is prayed over by holy men to make it pure. Bear in mind that animal sacrifice is also part of the monotheistic (Judaic, Christian, Isla...
Read more